Z-wave auto read switch status light Topic is solved

[EdddieN]

Hello,

I have most of my lights with Z-wave dimmers and switchers and they work ok, no issue there. However I noticed that when I trigger these manually (from the wall pad that sends the wired signal to the for example Fibaro switch), Domoticz does not have a log of it. I can see the logs when Domoticz triggers the event, but not when manually overrided by the wall switch.

Is this normal behaviour? I was keen to know more about my routines to start digging into ML....

Any thoughts... or do I just have an issue on my Z-wave network?

[gizmocuz]

Could you check in the manual if there is a 'group' that notifies the controller that there are updates ?
For example this could be Group 3, in that case, from the OpenZWave setup, select Groups&Network from the dropdown,
and add Node 1 (the controller) to this group for that node

[EdddieN]

Hi,

Thanks for the guidance. I think I understand what you mean. I have a Fibaro Dimmer
https://manuals.fibaro.com/content/manu ... T-v1.3.pdf

According to the manual I should add it to group 1:

The attachment Screen Shot 2018-09-12 at 16.31.06.png is no longer available

which it seems it is

The attachment Screen Shot 2018-09-12 at 16.28.14.png is no longer available

However my controller does not seem to belong to any group, is this right?

Screen Shot 2018-09-12 at 16.31.06.png (159.83 KiB) Viewed 1155 times

Does not seem right if I understand it correctly, is it?

[jvdz]

The controller needs to be in that "lifeline" group to receive the status. Just add that in there and check.

Jos

[EdddieN]

This is what I have, no option for adding group for the controller

Screen Shot 2018-09-12 at 16.32.32.png (102.5 KiB) Viewed 1152 times

It is all empty

[jvdz]

I am sorry but can't read that screen shot properly. It does look like there is a number in Group 1, which is the group the controller needs to be in.
Is that the controller number there?

EDIT: So it is the other way round: in this case the device group 1 needs to have deviceid of the controller in it. This should be the case for all devices, although the group ID can differ per device.

[EdddieN]

Sorry, let's try with bigger pictures.

I want to add this (which is already on group1)

Screen Shot 2018-09-12 at 17.13.31.png (22.47 KiB) Viewed 1136 times

to report status to the controller

However the controller does not have group:

Screen Shot 2018-09-12 at 17.13.22.png (36.15 KiB) Viewed 1136 times

[jvdz]

You are a little confused here.
So lets take de Hall. It has in Group1 the device 1 ( did you replace your controller that had deviceid 1 at the time?)
This group1 needs to contain the deviceid of your current controller, so should be 61.
There is no need to add anything to the controller itself, only to each device you want to control and receive the status for!
So when this work for Hall, you need to check/update all ZWAVE devices.
By the way: the CO2 sensor and Kitchen do have the proper value there (61) so guess they work fine?

Any clearer?
Jos

[EdddieN]

aaaahh!

yes, I did change the controller many times a while back (experimenting with different options)

Makes a lot of sense now, thanks so much

[EdddieN]

Hey! It turns it actually works!

Thanks so much for the clarification, I never quite understood what the groups did so my Z-wave network was a real mess . Manually updated it now

I guess the same applies for an alarm, right? so If I have a device alarm ID37, and I want a door to send a signal to it when open, then I would add it to group 37, right?

Anyway, the reporting work great now, updated from manual switch on Domoticz

hall.gif (91.39 KiB) Viewed 1100 times

[jvdz]

Hey! It turns it actually works!

yes of course (just kidding)

I guess the same applies for an alarm, right? so If I have a device alarm ID37, and I want a door to send a signal to it when open, then I would add it to group 37, right?

correct zwave devices can trigger actions directly like that without the controller in the middle.

Jos