FGSD 002 Fibaro Smoke sending false fire alert in Beta

dressie · Post by **dressie** » Saturday 04 July 2015 10:36

Hi all,

I did an update to V2.2622 this morning. Two hours later I got a fire alert from all of mine smoke detectors. The smoke detectors themself didn't make any sound, but it did trigger a scene in my home. Could this false alarm have anything to do with the update or is it pure coincidence? I couldn't find an options for the smoke detectors to sent out a monthly test alarm.

Did anybody else experienced this before?

Grtz,
Andres

Jantje1972 · Post by **Jantje1972** » Saturday 04 July 2015 14:02

The same smoke detector did send an alarm here this morning after the upgrade last night !

dressie · Post by **dressie** » Saturday 04 July 2015 18:25

Must be something with the update...time to roll back

dressie · Post by **dressie** » Sunday 05 July 2015 16:46

Before I rolled back to stable, I did another beta update but the problem kept coming back. It looks like when a smoke detector times out it starts creating a virtual fire-alarm. I rolled back to stable and the problem is gone. It must be some thing in de open Zwave.

ben92 · Post by **ben92** » Monday 06 July 2015 8:15

Hi i have same problem : false alert on FGSD.
Im on DZ 2638 and openzwave 399.

Alert happens at this time : 13h54 19h54 01h54.

gizmocuz · Post by **gizmocuz** » Monday 06 July 2015 8:23

It could be that it sends a 'keep alive' message, and as you do not hear the actual fire alarm, it looks like this.
please try the following:
- enable accept new hardware devices in the settings
- make the fire sensor go on, and check if you have a new device

i think you should have a new device that is the actual firealarm

ben92 · Post by **ben92** » Monday 06 July 2015 8:35

I did it but no New sensors.
When I click on thé button all alarm are set to on : fire ramper battery.

gizmocuz · Post by **gizmocuz** » Monday 06 July 2015 8:42

okey, and the notification message, you have set on the 'fire' switch ?

dressie · Post by **dressie** » Monday 06 July 2015 8:51

gizmocuz wrote:okey, and the notification message, you have set on the 'fire' switch ?

Same problem here, but what do you mean with this?

ben92 · Post by **ben92** » Monday 06 July 2015 10:42

I receive notification ALARM/FIRE

dressie · Post by **dressie** » Monday 06 July 2015 16:34

I keep on getting false fire-alerts....

frayman67 · Post by **frayman67** » Tuesday 07 July 2015 0:42

I'm also receiving false fire alarms and false temperature alarms for a few days on my 2 fgsd...

Domoticz latest beta on raspberry pi

dressie · Post by **dressie** » Tuesday 07 July 2015 10:32

Just did an upgrade to V2.2646 and within 4 minutes I got a false alarm from one of the fgsd again. Is there any sight yet on what could cause the problem? Really don't wanna downgrade to stable again...

ben92 · Post by **ben92** » Tuesday 07 July 2015 12:33

I think we must be patient, the team will find what happens.

You could see on SVN what the team commits, if nothing is in relation with openzwave, it's not worth update.

Zycker · Post by **Zycker** » Tuesday 07 July 2015 19:30

Hi, same problem here with my freshly received fgsd on v2622. I've had 4 false alarm within the 2 first days after the upgrade (receive mail notification for smoke & fire), the last one last for precisely 6 hours, just one second for the others.
As I write, the smoke and fire detectors haven't been seen since 2015-07-05, the last alarm in fact. The temperature sensor inside it report for the last time just one hour ago.

dressie · Post by **dressie** » Wednesday 08 July 2015 12:13

It got so badly that I rolled back. At one point you don't know if it's a real alert of a fake one. I'll wait till the problem is found.

frayman67 · Post by **frayman67** » Wednesday 08 July 2015 21:35

@dressie : To which version did you roll back?
Do you know which version of Domoticz introduces the bug?

dressie · Post by **dressie** » Wednesday 08 July 2015 22:46

frayman67 wrote:@dressie : To which version did you roll back?
Do you know which version of Domoticz introduces the bug?

I rolled back to stable, version V2.2563. The wife is happy again. No error anymore. .

gizmocuz · Post by **gizmocuz** » Friday 10 July 2015 16:50

hmmm nothing changed related to this... so i cant see what the stable version fixes

Jantje1972 · Post by **Jantje1972** » Friday 10 July 2015 17:04

Tested here as well, using stable version no more false fire/temperature alarms

FGSD 002 Fibaro Smoke sending false fire alert in Beta

FGSD 002 Fibaro Smoke sending false fire alert in Beta

Re: FGSD 002 Fibaro Smoke sending false fire alert.

Re: FGSD 002 Fibaro Smoke sending false fire alert.

Re: FGSD 002 Fibaro Smoke sending false fire alert.

Re: FGSD 002 Fibaro Smoke sending false fire alert in Beta

Re: FGSD 002 Fibaro Smoke sending false fire alert in Beta

Re: FGSD 002 Fibaro Smoke sending false fire alert in Beta

Re: FGSD 002 Fibaro Smoke sending false fire alert in Beta

Re: FGSD 002 Fibaro Smoke sending false fire alert in Beta

Re: FGSD 002 Fibaro Smoke sending false fire alert in Beta

Re: FGSD 002 Fibaro Smoke sending false fire alert in Beta

Re: FGSD 002 Fibaro Smoke sending false fire alert in Beta

Re: FGSD 002 Fibaro Smoke sending false fire alert in Beta

Re: FGSD 002 Fibaro Smoke sending false fire alert in Beta

Re: FGSD 002 Fibaro Smoke sending false fire alert in Beta

Re: FGSD 002 Fibaro Smoke sending false fire alert in Beta

Re: FGSD 002 Fibaro Smoke sending false fire alert in Beta

Re: FGSD 002 Fibaro Smoke sending false fire alert in Beta

Re: FGSD 002 Fibaro Smoke sending false fire alert in Beta

Re: FGSD 002 Fibaro Smoke sending false fire alert in Beta

Who is online