Fibaro Smoke Sensor2 (FGDS-002) not reporting temperature

[Egregius]

Very strange, keep playing/doing some of the stuff I did. It should work eventually.

[ropske]

i excluded the device again, did a reset of my smoke sensor and included it again; this is what shows up in my log:

2019-12-01 09:24:24.054 Status: New sensors allowed for 5 minutes...
2019-12-01 09:24:24.054 Status: OpenZWave: Node Include command initiated...
2019-12-01 09:24:54.595 OpenZWave: Value_Added: Node: 60 (0x3c), CommandClass: BATTERY, Label: Battery Level, Instance: 1, Index: 0
2019-12-01 09:24:54.812 OpenZWave: Value_Added: Node: 60 (0x3c), CommandClass: SENSOR BINARY, Label: Sensor, Instance: 1, Index: 0
2019-12-01 09:24:54.815 (RacoonCity) Light/Switch (Sensor)
2019-12-01 09:24:54.594 Status: OpenZWave: New Node added. HomeID: 3716775223, NodeID: 60 (0x3c)
2019-12-01 09:24:57.820 Status: OpenZWave: Received timeout notification from HomeID: 3716775223, NodeID: 60 (0x3c)
2019-12-01 09:24:58.079 OpenZWave: Value_Added: Node: 60 (0x3c), CommandClass: SENSOR MULTILEVEL, Label: Air Temperature, Instance: 1, Index: 1
2019-12-01 09:24:58.190 OpenZWave: Value_Added: Node: 60 (0x3c), CommandClass: ALARM, Label: Previous Event Cleared, Instance: 1, Index: 256
2019-12-01 09:24:58.191 OpenZWave: Value_Added: Node: 60 (0x3c), CommandClass: ALARM, Label: Smoke Alarm, Instance: 1, Index: 1
2019-12-01 09:24:58.194 (RacoonCity) Light/Switch (Smoke Alarm)
2019-12-01 09:24:58.233 OpenZWave: Value_Added: Node: 60 (0x3c), CommandClass: ALARM, Label: Heat, Instance: 1, Index: 4
2019-12-01 09:24:58.236 (RacoonCity) Light/Switch (Heat)
2019-12-01 09:24:58.275 OpenZWave: Value_Added: Node: 60 (0x3c), CommandClass: ALARM, Label: Home Security, Instance: 1, Index: 7
2019-12-01 09:24:58.277 (RacoonCity) Light/Switch (Home Security)
2019-12-01 09:24:58.316 OpenZWave: Value_Added: Node: 60 (0x3c), CommandClass: ALARM, Label: Power Management, Instance: 1, Index: 8
2019-12-01 09:24:58.319 (RacoonCity) Light/Switch (Power Management)
2019-12-01 09:24:58.357 OpenZWave: Value_Added: Node: 60 (0x3c), CommandClass: ALARM, Label: System, Instance: 1, Index: 9
2019-12-01 09:24:58.360 (RacoonCity) Light/Switch (System)
2019-12-01 09:24:58.623 OpenZWave: Value_Added: Node: 60 (0x3c), CommandClass: SENSOR ALARM, Label: General, Instance: 1, Index: 0
2019-12-01 09:24:58.625 (RacoonCity) Light/Switch (General)
2019-12-01 09:24:58.628 OpenZWave: Value_Added: Node: 60 (0x3c), CommandClass: SENSOR ALARM, Label: Smoke, Instance: 1, Index: 1
2019-12-01 09:24:58.629 OpenZWave: Value_Added: Node: 60 (0x3c), CommandClass: SENSOR ALARM, Label: Heat, Instance: 1, Index: 4
2019-12-01 09:24:58.191 Status: SendSwitchIfNotExists: Device '60.instance.1.index.256.commandClasses.113' (Previous Event Cleared) with DeviceID '00003C00' matches '60.instance.1.index.0.commandClasses.48' (Sensor). Domoticz will use the Dimmer (and hide the Switch).
2019-12-01 09:24:58.629 Status: SendSwitchIfNotExists: Device '60.instance.1.index.1.commandClasses.156' (Smoke) with DeviceID '00003C29' matches '60.instance.1.index.1.commandClasses.113' (Smoke Alarm). Domoticz will use the Dimmer (and hide the Switch).
2019-12-01 09:24:58.629 Status: SendSwitchIfNotExists: Device '60.instance.1.index.4.commandClasses.156' (Heat) with DeviceID '00003C2C' matches '60.instance.1.index.4.commandClasses.113' (Heat). Domoticz will use the Dimmer (and hide the Switch).
2019-12-01 09:25:00.636 (RacoonCity) General/kWh (kWh Meter)
2019-12-01 09:25:00.708 (RacoonCity) Usage (Unknown)
2019-12-01 09:25:00.714 (RacoonCity) General/kWh (kWh Meter)
2019-12-01 09:25:02.197 (RacoonCity) General/Alarm (Alarm Type: Home Security 7 (0x07))
2019-12-01 09:25:02.201 (RacoonCity) Light/Switch (Home Security)
2019-12-01 09:25:02.277 (RacoonCity) Light/Switch (General)
2019-12-01 09:25:02.315 (RacoonCity) Light/Switch (Smoke Alarm)
2019-12-01 09:25:02.354 (RacoonCity) Light/Switch (Heat)
2019-12-01 09:25:02.120 Status: OpenZWave: Received timeout notification from HomeID: 3716775223, NodeID: 60 (0x3c)
2019-12-01 09:25:02.195 Status: OpenZWave: Alarm received (Home Security: Tampering - Cover Removed), NodeID: 60 (0x3c)

What i noticed if that these 2 have the same index:
SENSOR MULTILEVEL, Label: Air Temperature, Instance: 1, Index: 1
ALARM, Label: Smoke Alarm, Instance: 1, Index: 1

Maybe these 2 are interrupting with eachother?

[ropske]

What type is your device @ Egregius?
0x1003 / 0x0c02 ?

Mine:
060 (0x3c) Rookmelder_Keuken FIBARO System FGSD002 Smoke Sensor+ FIBARO System 0x1003 0x0c02

[Egregius]

Mine are all:
FIBARO System FGSD002 Smoke Sensor+ FIBARO System 0x1002 0x0c02

I have no clue at all how the instances and indexes relate to each other.

[ropske]

I just tried the tamper alarm (cover mounted/not mounted) this status is reported to the controller.
I think i will need to contact the shop where i bought them (Robbshop) and try to return them i think.

Seems mine is another version as yours (0x1003) Maybe there is something else in it or i need another xml file

[ropske]

Hi mate, i think there is something else going on in my zwave network.
I don't know what it is exactly, but some of the temperatures of other devices are not reporting now also (fibaro motion sensor, fibaro door sensors)

What im having right now: i'm in the 'living' (sorry, dont know the english word lol)
and its veryyy hot in here.

If i check the status of my 'brander' in domoticz, it is off
when i check the openzwave panel, there it is on and if i check at the brander hardware itself, it is indeed running.
that explains the heat in my living.

I don't know why domoticz isn't updating properly.
Is it domoticz? is it zwave? is it my raspberry pi 3b+ ?

you can see it at the added pictures.

I will need to solve this, because i need to trust on this system it is working properly.
For the same money, i'm sleeping and my brander is working the whole night .....

[ropske]

hmm, what i tried this morning:

I have another Aeon Zwave Stick Gen5; i put this into my laptop, setup a windows domoticz running on stable on my laptop and added my 2 new smoke sensors and guess what, they are reporting directly at 0.1degree changement and else after 10minutes (the settings i configured)
So everything working nicely.
OpenZWave USB
Version: 1.4.3244.gbb874f6a.dirty



OpenZWave USB
Version: 1.6.954.gaa29b66e.dirty
Then i installed the windows beta version (like the one i'm running on my other setup on my Pi3b+)
and guess what? Smoke sensors are also reporting lol, but this is a different OpenZwave version 1.6.954 and on my pi it is: 1.6-943-gacce060e-dirty

When updating my Pi to latest beta version, the Openzwave version stays the same.
I will need to do a clean install again maybe?
I hope not ...

[ropske]

So 3 possible causes of the problem:
* Aeon Zwave Stick Gen5 (but i doubt it)
* OpenZwave version
* Hardware where Doomoticz is running (Raspberry Pi3b+ / Windows on laptop)

[ropske]

Someone has an idea? @Egregius ?

[Egregius]

How much fun can you have with it?

No, I don't have an idea. Think you did already all that's possible.
Either try with an older version on RPi, or run temporarily on Windows until a newer version for RPi comes out?

[ropske]

you were running Domoticz on a windows standalone system i thought i read somewhere?
What would you suggest? i better run it on a simular system instead of the Pi?


i'm kinda out of options

[Egregius]

No, I don’t like Windows. I’m running on Debian.

[ropske]

pfff, there is really something strange going on with my configuration.
when i want to load my Domoticz page now, it is not loading anymore, just like that.
I'm receiving this message in browser:

Deze pagina werkt niet192.168.1.143 heeft geen gegevens verzonden.
ERR_EMPTY_RESPONSE

[Egregius]

That's part of the service that's hung. Restart the service.
But normally, your cron.sh script from pass2php should take care of that.

[ropske]

already tried everything; 'again' ;(

if i check with: sudo service domoticz status
it says Domoticz is running.

But the webpage does not show up, php scripts are not running also (when i move in front of a motion sensor, the lights are not working)

Thinking of moving to Homey, but then I'm loosing the functionality of your pass2php
it was a long night lol, without result.

[Egregius]

Yes, that's the problem. status indicates it's running, but the webserver part isn't. Did you restart the service? Or rebooted the Rpi?

If you have €299 to spend do it on a Intel Nuc to run domoticz or another opensource package. I certainly wouldn't buy a commercial product for this. You will certainly be limited in the possibilities.

[ropske]

Yeah, already restarted the service, rebooted the Pi,...
Even reinstalled Domoticz, still not working, really strange.

Damned, i ordered it yesterday evening just before 0:00 so it is delivered today.
Maybe better send it back then? and buy the one like you say?

[Egregius]

Hard to say... Don't know Homey and their interface. Maybe it's good enough for your needs, maybe it isn't.
I can only say that my Domoticz runs rock solid, lightning fast and it does everything I want from it.

[Egregius]

BTW, I have Openzwave version 1.6.982 and after the update of today 1.6.992.

[ropske]

You just did ./updatebeta
?

I will need to reinstall my complete system to try it again,
Because with a ‘normal’ installation of Domoticz, it is not starting up