Page 3 of 4
Re: Confused about which device belong to which zwave-node
Posted: Friday 02 April 2021 0:27
by paalkr
I'm amazed that this is not part of Domoticz (anymore), and how hard it is to actually find zwave devices that belongs to the same unit. So I implemented a quickfix on top of Version: 2020.2 (build 12660) (I guess it will work on latest as well).
Now each z-wave device/unit is listed as a separate hardware, and selecting the z-wave device/unit (hardware) will filter the list for all related domoticz devices. It's possible to select multiple z-wave devices/units simultaneously.
I can make a PR if it's interesting to get this addition merged. No guarantee it will get accepted though.
- z-wave-devices.png (359.4 KiB) Viewed 1573 times
Re: Confused about which device belong to which zwave-node
Posted: Friday 02 April 2021 9:28
by lost
paalkr wrote: ↑Friday 02 April 2021 0:27
I can make a PR if it's interesting to get this addition merged. No guarantee it will get accepted thorough.
Crossing fingers!
Re: Confused about which device belong to which zwave-node
Posted: Friday 02 April 2021 9:56
by Plantje
Great work! Though, I am afraid it will not be accepted as gizmocuz has mentioned it is not a useful feature
Re: Confused about which device belong to which zwave-node
Posted: Friday 02 April 2021 11:04
by madpatrick
Maybe your can share the code as a diff.
Re: Confused about which device belong to which zwave-node
Posted: Tuesday 06 April 2021 23:35
by paalkr
Here is the PR
https://github.com/domoticz/domoticz/pull/4762
based on the work done by @jvdz
Re: Confused about which device belong to which zwave-node
Posted: Wednesday 07 April 2021 0:11
by paalkr
Re: Confused about which device belong to which zwave-node
Posted: Wednesday 07 April 2021 7:09
by Plantje
Yeah... I think rrozema gave up on that...
Re: Confused about which device belong to which zwave-node
Posted: Wednesday 07 April 2021 8:36
by paalkr
The PR got merged this morning
Re: Confused about which device belong to which zwave-node
Posted: Wednesday 07 April 2021 9:28
by jvdz
Plantje wrote: ↑Wednesday 07 April 2021 7:09
Yeah... I think rrozema gave up on that...
dunno about rrozema, but I clearly did.....and not to ne a spoilsport, my 3 line change was alo committed and part of a beta release for a while.
Re: Confused about which device belong to which zwave-node
Posted: Wednesday 07 April 2021 11:11
by paalkr
jvdz wrote: ↑Wednesday 07 April 2021 9:28
Plantje wrote: ↑Wednesday 07 April 2021 7:09
Yeah... I think rrozema gave up on that...
dunno about rrozema, but I clearly did.....and not to ne a spoilsport, my 3 line change was alo committed and part of a beta release for a while.
Yes, I know. Let's hope it will stay this time... The code is identical to what you provided, I just rebased it to the new devices code.
Re: Confused about which device belong to which zwave-node
Posted: Wednesday 07 April 2021 22:49
by jvdz
I hope so too and else simply merge it into the source whenever I update. ( Which is not likely to be anytime soon with all the issues I read with latest version of openzwave and its issues inside Domoticz.)
Re: Confused about which device belong to which zwave-node
Posted: Wednesday 07 April 2021 23:52
by paalkr
jvdz wrote: ↑Wednesday 07 April 2021 22:49
I hope so too and else simply merge it into the source whenever I update. ( Which is not likely to be anytime soon with all the issues I read with latest version of openzwave and its issues inside Domoticz.)
Yes, It's always easy to just merge it locally if it eventually get removed again
I have been running on latest for a long time now. What are the zwave problems reported by other users?
Re: Confused about which device belong to which zwave-node
Posted: Tuesday 04 May 2021 11:15
by waltervl
paalkr wrote: ↑Friday 02 April 2021 0:27
I'm amazed that this is not part of Domoticz (anymore), and how hard it is to actually find zwave devices that belongs to the same unit. So I implemented a quickfix on top of Version: 2020.2 (build 12660) (I guess it will work on latest as well).
Now each z-wave device/unit is listed as a separate hardware, and selecting the z-wave device/unit (hardware) will filter the list for all related domoticz devices. It's possible to select multiple z-wave devices/units simultaneously.
I can make a PR if it's interesting to get this addition merged. No guarantee it will get accepted though.
z-wave-devices.png
Just to confirm so I can update the wiki: This change is now in stable 2021.1 ? I have no ZWave so cannot check.
Re: Confused about which device belong to which zwave-node
Posted: Wednesday 05 May 2021 16:58
by paalkr
I'll have to look at the release notes to verify if it's in stable yet.
Re: Confused about which device belong to which zwave-node
Posted: Wednesday 05 May 2021 17:07
by waaren
waltervl wrote: ↑Tuesday 04 May 2021 11:15
Just to confirm so I can update the wiki: This change is now in stable 2021.1 ? I have no ZWave so cannot check.
Yes. In domoticz from build 13148
The domoticz release versions (aka stable) contain all fixes, updates , etc from earlier builds.
Re: Confused about which device belong to which zwave-node
Posted: Tuesday 18 May 2021 20:49
by Plantje
This is working great! Really happy with this feature. Thanks!
Re: Confused about which device belong to which zwave-node
Posted: Thursday 20 May 2021 22:43
by harrykausl
I am now on 2021.1. How can I get the mixed device/hardware tab. In devices tab, I can only see the devices, idx are highlighted. But I don‘t see the hardware list as it is shown in the picture above in this thread.
Re: Confused about which device belong to which zwave-node
Posted: Thursday 20 May 2021 22:47
by waaren
harrykausl wrote: ↑Thursday 20 May 2021 22:43
I am now on 2021.1. How can I get the mixed device/hardware tab. In devices tab, I can only see the devices, idx are highlighted. But I don‘t see the hardware list as it is shown in the picture above in this thread.
- select bar.png (42.88 KiB) Viewed 1312 times
Re: Confused about which device belong to which zwave-node
Posted: Thursday 20 May 2021 23:35
by harrykausl
Thanks!
Re: Confused about which device belong to which zwave-node
Posted: Friday 21 May 2021 7:25
by lost
waaren wrote: ↑Thursday 20 May 2021 22:47
...
Also searched a bit for this one
Looks this does not always show all devices in a z-wave node: Using this bar only shows relay control from my Qubino Smart-Meter... But search using the old hex node ID method still shows all devices (V/I/W/Cos Phy...). Others I checked (not all) looks OK.
Can't see how to put an image (needs an external URL) directly in the forum to show this, but that's what's happening.
