Page 1 of 4
Is there interest for Tellstick (Duo) support?
Posted: Sunday 30 August 2015 19:25
by mabo
At
https://github.com/martenbohlin/domoticz I have a clone of Domoticz with some basic suport for Tellstick. You can currently control switches and dimmers, but you have to configure them manually in /etc/tellstick.conf
So now I wonder if there is an interest from other Domoticz users for Tellstick support so I should add support for adding new devices etc
Let me know what you think.
Re: Is there interest for Tellstick (Duo) support?
Posted: Sunday 30 August 2015 20:39
by remb0
Maybe you can push your changes to the main github other devs can control and adapt them in de main?
Re: Is there interest for Tellstick (Duo) support?
Posted: Sunday 30 August 2015 20:47
by mabo
Absolutely, will someone give me permission to the main repository, or should I create a pull request?
I noticed that the telldus-core source is committed to the repository, I do not use these files. Instead I expect that telldus-core is installed on the system (can be installed with apt-get). Do you think I should the remove the telldus-core source file?
Re: Is there interest for Tellstick (Duo) support?
Posted: Sunday 30 August 2015 20:53
by remb0
I think that is a nice question voor Gizmocuz...
You expect that the core files are allready on the system? I think this is a little bit tricky. I think domoticz must include the things needed.. But hey: I'm not a dev...
Re: Is there interest for Tellstick (Duo) support?
Posted: Monday 31 August 2015 8:26
by gizmocuz
A pull request would be perfect.
I am not familiar with the tellstick, but when for instance a switch is received, is it not possible to add this automatically to the system (without config file)
How about headers/libs, will it build if these are not installed? or linked static ?
Re: Is there interest for Tellstick (Duo) support?
Posted: Monday 31 August 2015 17:33
by mabo
It would certainly be possible to do a much more elegant solution, but this is the minimal work to make a tellstick usable. My thought was to get it up here and see if there was any thing that people would use.
The CMakeLists.txt makes sure that the source includes tellstick if headers are available but skip the functionality if it is not present. I am not sure if it static or dynamically linked. I use the following in CMakeList.txt "target_link_libraries (domoticz telldus-core)"
I will add a instructions file and create a pull request so you can have a look at it.
Re: Is there interest for Tellstick (Duo) support?
Posted: Wednesday 02 September 2015 12:33
by PABben
Absolutely!
I've run tellstick duo for some years and just started with domoticz and rfxcom. The tellstick is very reliable on my sensors, but rfxcom misses alot of them.
Re: Is there interest for Tellstick (Duo) support?
Posted: Saturday 05 September 2015 13:01
by mabo
What sensors are you using? The current installation only supports on/off switches, but I would like to extend that.
Re: Is there interest for Tellstick (Duo) support?
Posted: Saturday 05 September 2015 13:59
by PABben
WT450H (Temp/humidity. These was working perfectly with tellstick through 6 walls but with rfxcom they are useless)
Nexa LMST-606 (magnet contact. Misses 50% of the values)
Nexa LBST-604 (Dusk sensor. Misses some values if the values are frequent)
Nexa WST-512 (Wall switch. I need to push and hold for 2-3 seconds several times)
Nexa LMDT-609 (Motion sensor. Misses some values if the values are frequent)
Also, tellstick has support for CoTech plug-in switches. I have 6 of those i can not use with rfxcom
Re: Is there interest for Tellstick (Duo) support?
Posted: Saturday 05 September 2015 17:49
by forumfab
I am interrested
Do you think that this could be extend to the tellstick.net
May be it should be possible to use the DOMOTICZ API to communicate with the module and the telldus core
Bests regards
Re: Is there interest for Tellstick (Duo) support?
Posted: Saturday 05 September 2015 22:46
by mabo
PABben: Except for the Temp/humidity sensor I think the other should work if you compile the current master branch of Domoticz. I do not have any sensors that sends data, so I can not test that.
Re: Is there interest for Tellstick (Duo) support?
Posted: Saturday 05 September 2015 22:49
by mabo
forumfab: It looks like supporting tellstick.net would be a completly different thing, and nothing that I plan to do.
Re: Is there interest for Tellstick (Duo) support?
Posted: Monday 07 September 2015 10:01
by forumfab
mabo wrote:forumfab: It looks like supporting tellstick.net would be a completly different thing, and nothing that I plan to do.
Hi mabo,
I am also interrested by the Tellstick DUO on DOMOTICZ
Bests regards
Thanks
Re: Is there interest for Tellstick (Duo) support?
Posted: Monday 07 September 2015 10:10
by PABben
mabo wrote:PABben: Except for the Temp/humidity sensor I think the other should work if you compile the current master branch of Domoticz. I do not have any sensors that sends data, so I can not test that.
The sensors are working, but my rfxcom is missing alot of the values.
I'm using windows server and have no idea about programming and compiling. That's why i'd like to see a "built in" support for tellstick
Re: Is there interest for Tellstick (Duo) support?
Posted: Monday 07 September 2015 13:57
by b_weijenberg
It is known that UPM/Esic sensors like WT440 are not very well received by the RFXtrx433. See chapter 2.2.2. (page 10) in the RFXtrx User Guide.
Correct working sensors are Oregon, Alecto, TFA, Cresta, Viking, LaCrosse, Proove....
Re: Is there interest for Tellstick (Duo) support?
Posted: Monday 07 September 2015 14:41
by PABben
b_weijenberg wrote:It is known that UPM/Esic sensors like WT440 are not very well received by the RFXtrx433. See chapter 2.2.2. (page 10) in the RFXtrx User Guide.
Correct working sensors are Oregon, Alecto, TFA, Cresta, Viking, LaCrosse, Proove....
I know, that's one of the reasons why i want support for tellstick
Re: Is there interest for Tellstick (Duo) support?
Posted: Monday 07 September 2015 20:48
by mabo
PABben wrote:
The sensors are working, but my rfxcom is missing alot of the values.
I'm using windows server and have no idea about programming and compiling. That's why i'd like to see a "built in" support for tellstick
I have some knowledge about programming, but I do not have windows. So unfortunately I can not verify if this is working on windows, and I can not provide you with a binary to test.
Re: Is there interest for Tellstick (Duo) support?
Posted: Friday 13 November 2015 6:55
by crone
I am interested for the Duo for sure!
Re: Is there interest for Tellstick (Duo) support?
Posted: Tuesday 17 November 2015 20:26
by alotam
+1 for Tellstick Duo support!
I have just begun my journey with domoticz, and I currently run HomeAutomation (
http://karpero.mine.nu/ha/) with a Tellstick Duo on a Raspberry Pi.
I was thinking I need to give up on the Tellstick and buy a rfxtrx device, to switch to domoticz.
But maybe not if this could be implemented relatively soon, yay!
Btw, I thought Tellstick devices ae just supposed to be read from tellstick.conf once you add the Tellstick Device in latest Domotics Beta?
Do I need to add them manually? I cant get it to work without using a dummy device (and then calling tdtool in the on/off actions).
Re: Is there interest for Tellstick (Duo) support?
Posted: Tuesday 17 November 2015 22:38
by mabo
A first implementation is already in the domoticz source. How to start using it is documented at this page:
http://www.domoticz.com/wiki/Basic_Tell ... h_Domoticz
I am also working on a improvment so you can detect new switches directly from domoticz