Domoticz

hjzwiers wrote:With Asus AImesh putting in both IP addresses does not work, still only sees the main router.

=arp fails, =brctl works

Just giving the info, I'll stick to brctl thnx

Is it easy/possible to temporarily switch off this AImesh feature? I suspect this is causing your problem.
On my system I have two routers (Asus and Linksys) just using the same SSID (but another channel), so no AImesh or anything. The plugin perfectly finds the correct HW methods on both routers, I don't need to force anything.

Hello there,

i would like to use this plugin to Vyos Router.

it show arp table to "show arp" command

If i try to add it to pre configured command i get this:

2018-10-12 12:51:05.898 Error: (teszt) Unsupported command (pre)configured for 192.168.31.1: show
2018-10-12 12:52:47.549 Error: (teszt) Failed 3 times to get capabilities for 192.168.31.1. Retry interval automatically reduced for this router

How to use your plugin it this router?

vamp wrote: ↑Friday 12 October 2018 12:53 Hello there,

i would like to use this plugin to Vyos Router.

it show arp table to "show arp" command

If i try to add it to pre configured command i get this:

2018-10-12 12:51:05.898 Error: (teszt) Unsupported command (pre)configured for 192.168.31.1: show
2018-10-12 12:52:47.549 Error: (teszt) Failed 3 times to get capabilities for 192.168.31.1. Retry interval automatically reduced for this router

How to use your plugin it this router?

It is better when you give the info you use in the plug-in.
Is SSH working to your router?

Try to use it like
Wifi router IP Address: <ip router>:<port number>=arp

Different SSH port
example: 192.168.31.1:8325=arp

Default SSH port
example: 192.168.31.1=arp

You only need to add the port number when you use a different port number for SSH to the router.

When it is not working make a screenshot of the plugin settings en mask the username and password

I found a other way

My Vyos VM run in a host (proxmox, Debian based) so i SSH to Proxmox and check brtcl. It working, but need some changes in python script.

I replace this line

from:
to:
It need, because Proxmox rename the normal bridge interface.

vmbr0 is the "LAN" virtual switch on Proxmox.

mikeoo wrote: ↑Friday 12 October 2018 7:20

AurelioF wrote: ↑Thursday 11 October 2018 15:10 I confirm that it works with Unifi AP Pro
Thanks for sharing

Do you use ARP with the Unifi. I use also Unifi and interesting how you use it.

My installation has two unifi devices, with a single ssid but two IP addresses.
the plugin is working on raspberry. I'm only using this plugin, I do not perform other ARP queries.
I have to say that sometimes I experience repeated reconnections on an iphone for no apparent reason, I am still investigating.

AurelioF wrote: ↑Monday 15 October 2018 10:26

mikeoo wrote: ↑Friday 12 October 2018 7:20

AurelioF wrote: ↑Thursday 11 October 2018 15:10 I confirm that it works with Unifi AP Pro
Thanks for sharing

Do you use ARP with the Unifi. I use also Unifi and interesting how you use it.

My installation has two unifi devices, with a single ssid but two IP addresses.
the plugin is working on raspberry. I'm only using this plugin, I do not perform other ARP queries.
I have to say that sometimes I experience repeated reconnections on an iphone for no apparent reason, I am still investigating.

I have an Edgerouter X and 3 Unifi AP but i can only use the Edgerouter for scanning the ip and app. Can you scan the AP directly for an ip ?

For 95% the plugin is working great. But sometimes a phone (android) is not at home but system still think it is, even after a few hours.
Reconnection i have also sometimes. Some day it is working great an then suddenly it disconnects for a few minutes and the comes back again.

Would Be nice if there was a better option then ARP with Unifi so we could kill this sort of problems.

mikeoo wrote: ↑Monday 15 October 2018 10:38

AurelioF wrote: ↑Monday 15 October 2018 10:26

mikeoo wrote: ↑Friday 12 October 2018 7:20

Do you use ARP with the Unifi. I use also Unifi and interesting how you use it.

My installation has two unifi devices, with a single ssid but two IP addresses.
the plugin is working on raspberry. I'm only using this plugin, I do not perform other ARP queries.
I have to say that sometimes I experience repeated reconnections on an iphone for no apparent reason, I am still investigating.

I have an Edgerouter X and 3 Unifi AP but i can only use the Edgerouter for scanning the ip and app. Can you scan the AP directly for an ip ?

For 95% the plugin is working great. But sometimes a phone (android) is not at home but system still think it is, even after a few hours.
Reconnection i have also sometimes. Some day it is working great an then suddenly it disconnects for a few minutes and the comes back again.

Would Be nice if there was a better option then ARP with Unifi so we could kill this sort of problems.

I access the unifi by IP and ssh using the plugin, I guess your unifi team must allow access by ssh, my unifi is "unifi ap pro"

AurelioF wrote: ↑Monday 15 October 2018 12:16

mikeoo wrote: ↑Monday 15 October 2018 10:38

AurelioF wrote: ↑Monday 15 October 2018 10:26

My installation has two unifi devices, with a single ssid but two IP addresses.
the plugin is working on raspberry. I'm only using this plugin, I do not perform other ARP queries.
I have to say that sometimes I experience repeated reconnections on an iphone for no apparent reason, I am still investigating.

I have an Edgerouter X and 3 Unifi AP but i can only use the Edgerouter for scanning the ip and app. Can you scan the AP directly for an ip ?

For 95% the plugin is working great. But sometimes a phone (android) is not at home but system still think it is, even after a few hours.
Reconnection i have also sometimes. Some day it is working great an then suddenly it disconnects for a few minutes and the comes back again.

Would Be nice if there was a better option then ARP with Unifi so we could kill this sort of problems.

I access the unifi by IP and ssh using the plugin, I guess your unifi team must allow access by ssh, my unifi is "unifi ap pro"

I have one UniFi AP-AC-LR and two UniFi AP-AC-Lite but as fas as i know iu can only be managed with Unify Controller or with the Android App but nut directly. I can SSH to the Edgerouter with putty but i need to sort out how to create SSH key for it. That part i have no experience in so but difficult for the moment. And don't know if that part gowning to work and if it fix the problem.

So if you one a share some info for how you did it But maby the Pro works different.

mikeoo wrote: ↑Monday 15 October 2018 12:45

AurelioF wrote: ↑Monday 15 October 2018 12:16

mikeoo wrote: ↑Monday 15 October 2018 10:38

I have an Edgerouter X and 3 Unifi AP but i can only use the Edgerouter for scanning the ip and app. Can you scan the AP directly for an ip ?

For 95% the plugin is working great. But sometimes a phone (android) is not at home but system still think it is, even after a few hours.
Reconnection i have also sometimes. Some day it is working great an then suddenly it disconnects for a few minutes and the comes back again.

Would Be nice if there was a better option then ARP with Unifi so we could kill this sort of problems.

I access the unifi by IP and ssh using the plugin, I guess your unifi team must allow access by ssh, my unifi is "unifi ap pro"

I have one UniFi AP-AC-LR and two UniFi AP-AC-Lite but as fas as i know iu can only be managed with Unify Controller or with the Android App but nut directly. I can SSH to the Edgerouter with putty but i need to sort out how to create SSH key for it. That part i have no experience in so but difficult for the moment. And don't know if that part gowning to work and if it fix the problem.

So if you one a share some info for how you did it But maby the Pro works different.

unifi ap pro has native SSH access, it is only necessary to configure user and password, it seems that unifi AP-AC-Lite and AP-AC-LR do not have ssh access, I did not know this difference, this can be a problem for your solution.
I do not know how to manage Edgerouter, if possible create a plain text key in your Edgerouter, using certificates is safer, but it is much more difficult.

if you can use a plain text password, make sure you have installed sshpass (sudo apt-get install sshpass). in Domoticz

AurelioF wrote: ↑Monday 15 October 2018 13:18

mikeoo wrote: ↑Monday 15 October 2018 12:45

AurelioF wrote: ↑Monday 15 October 2018 12:16

I access the unifi by IP and ssh using the plugin, I guess your unifi team must allow access by ssh, my unifi is "unifi ap pro"

I have one UniFi AP-AC-LR and two UniFi AP-AC-Lite but as fas as i know iu can only be managed with Unify Controller or with the Android App but nut directly. I can SSH to the Edgerouter with putty but i need to sort out how to create SSH key for it. That part i have no experience in so but difficult for the moment. And don't know if that part gowning to work and if it fix the problem.

So if you one a share some info for how you did it But maby the Pro works different.

unifi ap pro has native SSH access, it is only necessary to configure user and password, it seems that unifi AP-AC-Lite and AP-AC-LR do not have ssh access, I did not know this difference, this can be a problem for your solution.
I do not know how to manage Edgerouter, if possible create a plain text key in your Edgerouter, using certificates is safer, but it is much more difficult.

if you can use a plain text password, make sure you have installed sshpass (sudo apt-get install sshpass). in Domoticz

tnx that is different indeed. For now i am working with just the password and sshpass indeed and that is working but with sometimes a problem. But wil search for hopefully other option witch works better in the future.

How do we use asp plugin to Optus router?
Optus Technical Support Number

how do we use asp plugging to my republic broadband?
Myrepublic internet support

@jackjhon

Ik you can supply a router make and model, then maybe someone can help you.
In general: if the router supports ssh just follow the instructions on GitHub. If it doesn't the plugin will not work with your router.

This plugin is exactly what I need! Sadly it's not compatible with my router My router supports SSH, but the commands your script is trying to execute are not found. Debug output is as follows:
My router make and model is: Mikrotik RouterBoard RB962UiGS-5HacT2HnT hAP AC

Of the commands your script is trying to execute, only the ARP command is available but has the following syntax: Do you think it would be possible to make the script compatible with my router? How can I help?

Thank you!

@Freekers

It seems the routeros on the MikroTik offers ssh for it's own configuration environment, but no real linux/busybox command line. If you can find a command that will produce a clean list of mac addresses then i can add that to the plugin as a preconfigured command.

After some searching on the MikroTik website i suspect that the router does not have the 'awk' command needed to filter only the mac-addresses from the arp table. Can you find another way to get a clean list of mac addresses from the routeros command line?

Maybe something like: (taken some pointers from the MikroTik website, but i have no idea if this combination will work)

The router also seems to offer scripting capabilities, so maybe you can cook up a script for routeros that will produce a clean list of mac addresses(?)

Auto detection of the router type by the plugin will not work because the (current) router side script expects some linux/busbox command to be available. Not just a proprietary set of tools. That's not a huge problem though, since the plugin already offers an option to force a preconfigured command. I will simply add such a command for the MikroTik to the plugin. If you can come up with a safe way to detect routerOS as the router type (without the test crashing the detection script on other router types), then i can even have a look at auto detection.

@Freekers

I have an idea to support custom commands in the plugin and not assume the output is always formatted correctly for the plugin. This way support for MikroTik and other obscure routers/accespoints can be easily added.

Will publish a new version today or at least this weekend (depending on the test results and effort

**version 0.7.4**
- Changed: different approach to parse mac addresses from (potentially unformatted) router data
- Added: Custom command for MikroTik RouterOS (configure router address in the plugin as: <routerip>=routeros eg. 192.168.0.1=routeros).
Note: routeros uses the arp detection method but with a different syntax and the mac address parsing is handled by the plugin instead of the router side script.

i guys, sorry but if i have fritzbox that not support telnet i can't use this plugin?

tnx

EscApe wrote: ↑Saturday 27 October 2018 13:22 @Freekers

I have an idea to support custom commands in the plugin and not assume the output is always formatted correctly for the plugin. This way support for MikroTik and other obscure routers/accespoints can be easily added.

Will publish a new version today or at least this weekend (depending on the test results and effort

Wow, this is awesome! I've just tested the new version and I can confirm that it works Great work, thank you very much for the quick fix!!

Do you still need more debug information to further optimize the script? Since it's based on the arp table, it takes a while for the MAC address to get removed from the arp table after the connection has been dropped/disconnected. Would it help to force a refresh of the arp table after every query, like so? https://forum.mikrotik.com/viewtopic.php?t=11030

Glad it's working

You might be able to tweak arp table management on the routerboard. Maybe set some time-outs(?) I don't know the platform, but it seems well documented and very tweakable. Refreshing the arp table on every polls seems a bit drastic. The plugin might miss mac addresses if the table isn't refreshed quick enough.

Querying the wireless interfaces will probably work much better than the generic arp command. You could investigate how to get the associated mac addresses from the wireless chipset. That is where the plugin is at is best.

Another question to really support RouterOS in the plugin is how to detect the routerboard as a routerboard with a command that will consistently identify the routerboard and that will consistently fail on other routers/firmwares. That way it can be included in the auto detection mechanism of the plugin.
Eg.
To check if a router has a broadcom chipset the plugin will try to run: 'type wl' on the router. type will return an error code if the wl command is not available. The plugin uses this info (and more checks like that) to identify the router. Since routeros offers no real linux-like shell the 'type'' test will not work.