Page 2 of 2
Re: Zigbee devices not responding after long power outage
Posted: Saturday 12 October 2019 9:42
by pipiche
You are mixing pairing a new device , and rejoining the network when the device has to left it on purpose and was just not reachable (power outage)
Re: Zigbee devices not responding after long power outage
Posted: Saturday 12 October 2019 11:10
by Thorgal789
lost wrote: ↑Saturday 12 October 2019 7:55
Maybe because they auto-re-attach them when plugged back on, if detach from a missed controller is the normal zibgee device behavior. But this may not save you from any detach related situation: This also means anyone doing an attach nearby would get your devices in his own network?!!
I m saying perhaps Xiaomi make something working but only for him ATM, I just want to say it's not a Zigbee protocol problem.
And no it s not so easy, during the first inclusion devices have exchange somes keys to securise the inclusion, just open your network is not enought to recover all devices that want to rejoin a network.
For me Xiaomi is the only manufacturer that cause problem, all other device can rejoin my network if I stop my gateway during 24h (perhaps a powercycle for some of them, but don't need if its a power lost ). Device Xiaomi leave the network, but only them, if you use a philips sensor you will not have this problem. Xiaomi device are cheaper but crappy.
The problem is not zigbee, he is Xiaomi.
Re: Zigbee devices not responding after long power outage
Posted: Saturday 12 October 2019 16:58
by pipiche
Thorgal789 wrote: ↑Saturday 12 October 2019 11:10
lost wrote: ↑Saturday 12 October 2019 7:55
Maybe because they auto-re-attach them when plugged back on, if detach from a missed controller is the normal zibgee device behavior. But this may not save you from any detach related situation: This also means anyone doing an attach nearby would get your devices in his own network?!!
I m saying perhaps Xiaomi make something working but only for him ATM, I just want to say it's not a Zigbee protocol problem.
And no it s not so easy, during the first inclusion devices have exchange somes keys to securise the inclusion, just open your network is not enought to recover all devices that want to rejoin a network.
For me Xiaomi is the only manufacturer that cause problem, all other device can rejoin my network if I stop my gateway during 24h (perhaps a powercycle for some of them, but don't need if its a power lost ). Device Xiaomi leave the network, but only them, if you use a philips sensor you will not have this problem. Xiaomi device are cheaper but crappy.
The problem is not zigbee, he is Xiaomi.
correct !
Re: Zigbee devices not responding after long power outage
Posted: Saturday 12 October 2019 17:40
by domogijs
okok pipiche i owe you an apology; I messed up ikea bulbs, and tried over and over to rejoin an none zigbee ikea bulb......
When i used the right ikea bulb, it worked like a charm
I get a little cranky when the waf is declining.
Keep up the good work
Greets Gijs
Re: Zigbee devices not responding after long power outage
Posted: Saturday 12 October 2019 18:22
by pipiche
No issue!
Envoyé de mon iPhone en utilisant Tapatalk